Taylor Michael. Rationality and the Ideology of Disconnection

Cambridge University Press, 2006. — 239 p.Rationality and the Ideology of Disconnection is a powerful and provocative critique of the foundations of Rational Choice theory and the economic way of thinking about the world, written by a former leading practitioner. The target is a dehumanizing ideology that cannot properly recognize that normal people have attachments and commitments to other people and to practices, projects, principles, and places, which provide them with desire-independent reasons for action, and that they are reflective creatures who think about what they are and what they should be, with ideals that can shape and structure the way they see their choices. The author’s views are brought to bear on the economic way of thinking about the natural environment and on how and when the norm of fair reciprocity motivates us to do our part in cooperative endeavors. Throughout, the argument is adorned by thought-provoking examples that keep what is at stake clearly before the reader’s mind.To anyone who wishes to grasp what matters in the nowhighly charged debate about rational choice theory, this book is indispensable.
Michael Taylor is a professor of political science at the University of Washington in Seattle. He has taught previously at the University of Essex in England and at Yale University. He was for many years a leading practitioner of rational choice theory and published two influential books on cooperation in the absence of centralized coercion: Anarchy and Cooperation (later revised as The Possibility of Cooperation, 1987) and Community, Anarchy, and Liberty (1982).